Basically there are three controversial bugaboos in Christian fiction: language, sensuality, and violence.
Should there be any? How much is too much? Who gets to decide?
As a baseline when I'm writing, I first look to Jesus when I create my heroes. With that in mind...
But that's just me. Who really gets to decide what goes into a piece of Christian fiction? The author, the publisher or the reader?
Ultimately, I'd say the reader and publisher are tied for first place. An author can write whatever he/she wants, but if a publisher or reader doesn't pick it up, it's kind of a moot point. A reader is only going to buy what they like to read, and a publisher is going to put out what a reader wants to read, so that's why I give them equal weight.
Great stories can be told without the use of F-bombs, literary porn, and guns galore. Sometimes those are merely crutches to prop up a weak plot.
As a baseline when I'm writing, I first look to Jesus when I create my heroes. With that in mind...
- Jesus didn't use vulgar language even when nailed on the cross, though I suspect we all would've cut Him some slack for a few slipped curses.
- Jesus loved with every pore in his body but not in an erotic way.
- Jesus had violence committed against him but did not commit violence Himself. Yet. He will return astride a white horse someday and be armed for battle, though of what kind, I'm not sure.
But that's just me. Who really gets to decide what goes into a piece of Christian fiction? The author, the publisher or the reader?
Ultimately, I'd say the reader and publisher are tied for first place. An author can write whatever he/she wants, but if a publisher or reader doesn't pick it up, it's kind of a moot point. A reader is only going to buy what they like to read, and a publisher is going to put out what a reader wants to read, so that's why I give them equal weight.
Great stories can be told without the use of F-bombs, literary porn, and guns galore. Sometimes those are merely crutches to prop up a weak plot.

6 comments:
This seems to be a hot issue right now. Keep hearing it discussed.
I tend to lean with you on this debate.
Honey CHILD, I have been commenting on this rigorously on some blogs lately. Anyway, I think the publishers (specifically, the CBA) are supposed to be the gatekeepers. When they're NOT acting in that capacity, just publishing things regardless of language, they need to be held accountable. My MS is out at one of these publishers, and I have a feeling they're not going to want to take me on as a client b/c of my vocal stand against vulgarities in Christian fiction. Oh, well.
Hey...if nothing else, at least I'm trendy, right?
We Viking-writers are the TRENDIEST. Many of the publishers just haven't realized that yet. Grin.
Totally with you, Michelle -- i don't understand why some authors have to actually spell out the bad word. It doesn't make the characters more real to me. And you can write a great romance without all the sensuality. I recently read a book by a Christian author that had an unnecessary wedding night scene at the very end. I was like really? There's no point to it.
Christian authors and publishers need to be careful. The world is watching, and all too eager to brand us hypocrites.
Good reminder about the world watching, Gwen. Even more important...God is watching.
Post a Comment